Readers’ impression of the Survival Guide
Tags: Ad Lagendijk, Survival GuidePosted in Tips for junior scientists, Tips for senior scientists
When talking about the Survival Guide, I have heard from several people some strikingly similar opinions. The first and the second sentences are usually something like “I agree with [the author: Ad]…” or “I checked it for preparing one of my presentations. It was rather helfpul…”. By the third sentence, many readers whom I talked to cannot avoid expressing their surprise about the style of the book. Here are some examples:”It is written in a very strange way.” “I did not like the [imperative] tone.” “Ad must be a tough guy.”
Although I never got offended myself by the intonation used in the Survival Guide, I think I can understand why some readers find it offensive. First of all, it is just unusual. Furthermore, it is commanding and strict. When Ad states a new tip in his book, he usually leaves no room for some similar opinion to exist. I would not be the first one to see, in this sense, a similarity with the Bible (Read the comment of Jos Wassink for this post, in Dutch). I can tell you that Quran has also a similar style. However, in my opinion, the most similar(in style) book to the Survival Guide is The Art of War from San Tzu (~1100 AD). Just read some quotes and you will probably agree with me.












Readers' comments
The fact that my idea was used by someone means that my scientific behavior is not original, that is normal. ...
24 Aug 2010 17:24, Vitaliy
Have you tried Mendeley? Looks like an interesting alternative to EndNote.
24 Aug 2010 15:30, Witek
I'm experimenting with a new theme for another Wordpress blog that uses #666 and came across your post. It's on ...
14 Aug 2010 23:59, Donna B.
Ah, a lot of interesting issues regarding patents I think. Maybe the most interesting question is what is ethical to ...
12 Aug 2010 19:12, Mirjam
I like the idea of an article written not in a linear style but rather like a wikipedia entry, because ...
12 Aug 2010 2:35, Wolfgang