Readers’ impression of the Survival Guide
Tags: Ad Lagendijk, Survival GuidePosted in Miscellaneous, Tips for junior scientists, Tips for senior scientists
When talking about the Survival Guide, I have heard from several people some strikingly similar opinions. The first and the second sentences are usually something like “I agree with [the author: Ad]…” or “I checked it for preparing one of my presentations. It was rather helfpul…”. By the third sentence, many readers whom I talked to cannot avoid expressing their surprise about the style of the book. Here are some examples:”It is written in a very strange way.” “I did not like the [imperative] tone.” “Ad must be a tough guy.”
Although I never got offended myself by the intonation used in the Survival Guide, I think I can understand why some readers find it offensive. First of all, it is just unusual. Furthermore, it is commanding and strict. When Ad states a new tip in his book, he usually leaves no room for some similar opinion to exist. I would not be the first one to see, in this sense, a similarity with the Bible (Read the comment of Jos Wassink for this post, in Dutch). I can tell you that Quran has also a similar style. However, in my opinion, the most similar(in style) book to the Survival Guide is The Art of War from San Tzu (~1100 AD). Just read some quotes and you will probably agree with me.







Readers' comments
(I'm typing this comment for the third time now... *sigh*) Many people don't know this, but Google Docs has a built-in ...
9 Mar 2010 23:47, cpbotha
For senior scientists it may be a conscious (although stupid) choice to give a talk to impress people, instead of ...
9 Mar 2010 10:35, Mirjam
What do you mean by 'pointing stick'? Obviously, we don't live in an ideal world, but fortunately most scientists will ...
22 Jan 2010 8:28, Mirjam
What about academia.edu? My impression was that they aspire to become a kind of "Facebook for scientists".
14 Jan 2010 22:32, Researcher
Yep, I sympathize with you. Last spring I taught a bachelor course for Electrical Engineering students, and although most of ...
9 Dec 2009 11:31, Nicole de Beer