Drop your stories

Send your own story, or look for an idea at our lists of topics in our Send your own story page.

Topic: Ethics

jErOEn jErOEn 9 October 2013

Missed references

Posted in Ethics

no credit 150x150 Missed referencesAs a scientist reading a substantial amount of papers I regularly read articles with inadequate referencing. Obviously some papers contain too many self-citations, however my main concern is about missed references. Why are the (co-)authors missing references to crucial and important work of others or, more worrisome on a personal level, to my own work? Here I would like to discuss this issue in more detail.

4 Reactions. Your reaction is also very welcome»  
Sanli Sanli 27 April 2013

A close encounter with Diederik Stapel and his act of fraud

Tags: ,
Posted in Ethics, High-impact journals, politics

Yudhijit Bhattacharjee, a staff writer at Science magazine, has written an elegant article in the New York Times about the Dutch psychologist Diederik Stapel. The scientific misconduct of Stapel, including fabrication of data for at least 30 publications, outraged the scientific community a couple of years ago. At that time Stapel was the dean of the social and behavioral sciences faculty at the Tilburg university. He returned his [cum laude] Ph.D. title to the University of Amsterdam in November 2011, noting that his “behavior of the past years are inconsistent with the duties associated with the doctorate.”

1 Reaction. Your reaction is also very welcome»  
Frerik van Beijnum Frerik van Beijnum 7 October 2012

Inviting co-authors

Tags: , , , , ,
Posted in Ethics, Getting published, PhD life

A problem I often encounter is deciding who to invite as co-authors. On one hand, you want to show appreciation to the people that helped you in the process of obtaining your results. On the other hand, generously adding authors will dilute the contribution of the people that made the largest contribution. In this post I would like to sketch a few hypothetical situations in which someone could be a co-author. The main goal here is to provoke some discussion on this subject, and learn about some good practices.

7 Reactions. Your reaction is also very welcome»  
Sanli Sanli 5 May 2012

Academia can benefit a lot from a more democratic funding system

Tags: , ,
Posted in Ethics, politics, Web 2.0

Much more has been said about the failure of current grant system than that has actually changed. My favorite opinion piece is this one by Peter A. Lawrence. The single-sentence abstract says it all: “The granting system turns young scientists into bureaucrats and then betrays them.” There are a couple of suggestions for improving the funding distribution in that article but the title of a comment by Markus Noll says enough about why nothing is changing: “Scientists in power will never change their system unless forced.”

10 Reactions. Your reaction is also very welcome»